Answer: The Butter Ball.
More Classic Riddles with answers
Previous: When young, I am sweet in the sun. When middle-aged, I make you gay. When old, I am valued more than ever. What am I?
Next: Whether old Homer tippled wine or beer, Julep or cider, history is not clear; But plain it is-the bard, though want to roam, But for one liquid, never had left home. What is it?