I ate one and threw away two

Answer: oyster

More Food Riddles with answers

More Food Riddles

I come out of the earth, I am sold in the market. He who buys me cuts my tail, takes off my suit of silk, and weeps beside me when I am dead.
I'm a blended cold beverage made up of milk, ice cream and fruit. I bring all the boys to the yard.
I'm a dish of ground meat formed into a loaf shape, mixed with egg and breadcrumbs, then baked or smoked
I'm a flat circular spongy roll made from yeast dough and eaten toasted and buttered
I'm a food made of flour, water, and yeast or another leavening agent, mixed together and baked. You need me to make a sandwich.
I'm a fruit that grows on a tree. Some of my varieties include Red Delicious and Granny Smith.
I'm a long, green-skinned fruit with watery flesh, usually eaten raw in salads or pickled.
I'm a lot like a pancake, except I'm a little crisper, and I'm square, with square patterns all over.
I'm a pie, but I come with peperoni and cheese
I'm a small sweet cake, typically round, flat, and crisp. I come in a variety of flavors from chocolate chip to oatmeal raisin.
I'm a soft, sweet food made from a mixture of flour, shortening, eggs, sugar, and other ingredients, baked and often decorated.
I'm a thick slice of beef or other high-quality meat or fish that is often cooked on a grill or fried.